Worked examples · illustrative
Three pieces of signed work. One from each field.
Finance, tax and real estate are the fields we know best, and the method is the same wherever an expert signs the work. Each shows where the use of AI succeeds, and where it fails: the AI's draft passes its checks, and the judgement turns on something else. In each, most of what the AI did was right and need not be done again. A good way of working keeps that, and puts the expert on what the AI could not settle. Try each review yourself.
Finance · financial due diligence
Every balance agrees. One rests on an estimate.
A buyer has asked for financial due diligence on a specialist contractor. Management's adjusted EBITDA is £3.0m, and the buyer values the business at six times that, £18.0m, on a locked box at the year end. The AI has agreed the contract revenue to the schedule and drafted the section. The partner who signs the report decides what the buyer is told before the price is fixed.
- Largest contract£6.0m
- Stage of completion70% at the year end
- Margin recognised£840k, agrees to the schedule
- Contract loss£250k, added back as non-recurring
Your name goes on the report
The draft is on your desk. What would you open first?
The contract schedule the balances were agreed to and the June contract review are in the data room. Each is one click and a slow read away.
You checked the contract schedule
Every balance agrees. It is easy to stop here.
- A June review, after the year end, raised the cost to complete by £450k. On that estimate the contract was 64% complete at the year end, with £480k of margin earned.
- On the same estimate, the £600k contract balance in the locked box is £240k.
- The £250k loss on a "legacy contract" is added back as non-recurring. A loss-making contract appears in each of the two years before, under other names.
- The year
- £360k of the year's EBITDA is in question. At six times, that is £2.16m of price.
- The box
- £360k less in the contract balance. A locked box is never trued up.
- The loss
- £310k and £180k in the two years before. A one-off, or a cost of contracting.
Every balance in the draft agrees to its schedule. The schedule rests on an estimate that nobody tested.
You opened the June contract review
That is where it was.
- A June review, after the year end, raised the cost to complete by £450k. On that estimate the contract was 64% complete at the year end, with £480k of margin earned.
- On the same estimate, the £600k contract balance in the locked box is £240k.
- The £250k loss on a "legacy contract" is added back as non-recurring. A loss-making contract appears in each of the two years before, under other names.
- The year
- £360k of the year's EBITDA is in question. At six times, that is £2.16m of price.
- The box
- £360k less in the contract balance. A locked box is never trued up.
- The loss
- £310k and £180k in the two years before. A one-off, or a cost of contracting.
A better design lists what rests on an estimate, sets each beside the latest view of it, and leaves the judgement to you.
- As drafted£3.0m
- If the June estimate is taken back to the year end£2.64m
- If the contract loss is also not added back£2.39m
At six times: £18.0m
And £360k less in the locked-box balance sheet.
Where the expert thinks
Two judgements. See what the price carries.
The AI agreed every balance. Whether June's news belongs in the year, and whether a contract loss is a one-off, are judgements. The price is fixed on the answer.
The AI does
- Reads every contract and cost report
- Agrees revenue and contract balances to the schedule
- Links each adjustment to its document
Together
- List what rests on an estimate
- Set each contract's forecast beside how it turned out
- Show the case for and against each adjustment
The expert decides
- Whether the estimate was sound when it was made
- Whether a loss is a one-off or a cost of contracting
- What the buyer is told before the price is fixed
| The draft, as the AI tied it | The data room also shows | What turns on it | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The largest contract | A £6.0m contract, 70% complete at the year end. Margin recognised: £840k. Agrees to the contract schedule. | The June review adds £450k to the cost to complete. On that estimate it was 64% complete, measured by cost, with £480k of margin earned. | Whether £360k of the year's EBITDA had been earned by the year end. |
| The one-off | A £250k loss on a "legacy contract", added back as non-recurring. Linked to the board paper. | A loss-making contract in each of the two years before, under other names: £310k and £180k. | Whether a bad contract is a one-off, or a cost of being a contractor. |
| The locked box | £600k recoverable on that contract, in the year-end balance sheet. Agrees to the schedule. | On the June estimate the balance is £240k. | A locked box is never trued up. Unless the price is adjusted for it, a pound of contract balance that is not there is a pound overpaid. |
ICAEW's best-practice guideline on financial due diligence covers the use of AI with human oversight. The sign-off record shows what that oversight was.
For the partners and directors who sign financial due diligence.Get the finance pack
Tax · a research and development relief claim
Every cost agrees to payroll. The engineers' notes say something else.
A company claims research and development relief on a new pricing engine. The AI has read the project documents and drafted the technical narrative. Qualifying costs are £410k. The partner whose name is on the file decides what the firm will put its name to.
- ProjectNew pricing engine
- Advance sought"A novel optimisation method"
- Uncertainty"Not resolvable from public knowledge"
- Qualifying costs£410k
Your name is on the file
The draft is on your desk. What would you open first?
The payroll records behind the costs and the engineers' own notes are on the file. Each is one click and a long read away.
You checked the costs to payroll
Every cost agrees. It is easy to stop here.
- The engineers' notes say the team configured a commercially available optimisation library.
- The open point the draft describes was closed by a supplier support ticket in two days.
- About 40% of the cost, £164k, is data migration.
- The notes also show eleven weeks spent making the library do something its documentation did not cover.
- The work
- The notes point both ways: a library anyone could buy, and eleven weeks beyond its documentation.
- The cost
- Without the data migration, the costs are at most £246k.
- The claim
- Several positions are defensible, from a reduced claim to none.
Every cost in the claim agrees to payroll. Whether the work sought an advance is a judgement, and the payroll cannot make it.
You opened the engineers' notes
That is where it was.
- The engineers' notes say the team configured a commercially available optimisation library.
- The open point the draft describes was closed by a supplier support ticket in two days.
- About 40% of the cost, £164k, is data migration.
- The notes also show eleven weeks spent making the library do something its documentation did not cover.
- The work
- The notes point both ways: a library anyone could buy, and eleven weeks beyond its documentation.
- The cost
- Without the data migration, the costs are at most £246k.
- The claim
- Several positions are defensible, from a reduced claim to none.
A better design sets each statement in the narrative beside its source, and leaves the position to you.
The AI does
- Reads the project documents and timesheets
- Maps costs to categories
- Drafts the narrative, once the position is decided
Together
- Test each statement against its source
- Separate what is asserted from what is evidenced
- Set each cost beside the work it paid for
The expert decides
- Whether there was an advance
- Whether the uncertainty was real
- Which costs qualify, and what goes on file
| The AI's draft says | The engineers' notes say | What turns on it | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The advance | The team developed "a novel optimisation method". | The team configured a commercially available optimisation library. | Whether the work sought an advance, or applied capability that already existed. |
| The uncertainty | It was "not resolvable from public knowledge". | The open point the draft describes was closed by a supplier support ticket in two days. | Whether a competent professional could readily have worked it out. |
| The cost | £410k of cost, all of it inside the project. | About 40% of it, £164k, is data migration. | Where the project begins and ends, and which costs sit inside it. |
Professional Conduct in Relation to Taxation asks a member to act with due care, and not to be knowingly associated with a false or misleading statement. The government's guidelines on the meaning of R&D ask whether a competent professional could readily have worked the answer out.
For the partners and directors who sign relief claims.Get the tax pack
Real estate · a valuation for secured lending
The lease summary was accurate. The break option was in the side letter.
A multi-let office, valued for secured lending. The AI was given the lease folder, and has summarised the leases into the tenancy schedule. The signing valuer decides whether to adopt it.
- Passing rent£1.42m a year
- Unexpired term7.4 years
- Tenant breaksNone noted
- IncentivesNone noted
Your name goes on the valuation
The draft is on your desk. What would you open first?
The leases the schedule was built from and the side letters are in the data room. Each is one click and a slow read away.
You checked the leases
Every lease agrees. It is easy to stop here.
- A side letter gives the largest tenant, 31% of the rent, a break at year three of its lease, on six months' notice.
- A second grants another tenant nine months rent-free on renewal.
- The lease summary was accurate. The terms that move the value were somewhere else.
- The term
- 7.4 years on the schedule. About 5.2 years to the earliest break, if that lease has 9 years to run and the break is 2 years away.
- The income
- £440k a year of rent can leave.
What a break and a rent-free period do to the value is your judgement. You were never shown them.
You opened the side letters
That is where it was.
- A side letter gives the largest tenant, 31% of the rent, a break at year three of its lease, on six months' notice.
- A second grants another tenant nine months rent-free on renewal.
- The lease summary was accurate. The terms that move the value were somewhere else.
- The term
- 7.4 years on the schedule. About 5.2 years to the earliest break, if that lease has 9 years to run and the break is 2 years away.
- The income
- £440k a year of rent can leave.
A better design lists every document read and every one not, and leaves the judgement to you.
Follow one engagement with a lender's credit team, step by step
The AI does
- Reads the leases and side letters
- Extracts the terms
- Assembles the comparable evidence
Together
- Mark what was found and what was not
- Reconcile the tenancy schedule to the documents
- Set competing evidence side by side
The expert decides
- The weight each comparable carries
- What a break or an incentive does to the value
- The figure, and the basis it is reported on
| The AI's schedule says | The side letters say | What turns on it | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The term | WAULT of 7.4 years. "No breaks noted." | The largest tenant can break at year three, on six months' notice. | The term certain. If that lease has 9 years to run and the break is 2 years away, the weighted term to the earliest break is about 5.2 years. |
| The income | Passing rent of £1.42m a year. The largest tenant pays 31% of it. | That tenant's £440,000 a year can leave. | The income the lender treats as secure, and the void and re-letting assumptions behind it. |
| The renewals | Nothing recorded. | Another tenant has nine months rent-free on renewal. | The cash flow at that lease event, and what the incentive says about the rental tone of the building. |
The RICS standard on the responsible use of AI, in force since 9 March 2026, requires a written decision on reliability by a named surveyor where an AI output has a material impact, and gives no method for reaching it.
Ten pages. Pages 2 to 4 take five minutes.Get the real estate pack
Start here
Get the pack for your field.
Ten pages. Pages 2 to 4 take five minutes.
- The decision and the grey area
- Why the obvious fixes fail
- The way of working we would design, with a sample sign-off record
- What it means for value and for your people
- How we would show it on your own work, and the sources
Thirty minutes with our founder, not a salesperson. Bring one workflow, with no client details, and we will sketch where AI could matter in it.
Arrange the 30 minutes